Lucas critique

Lucas critique

The Lucas Critique, named for Robert Lucas's work on macroeconomic policymaking, says that it is naive to try to predict the effects of a change in economic policy entirely on the basis of relationships observed in historical data, especially highly aggregated historical data.

The basic idea pre-dates Lucas's contribution, but in a 1976 paper he drove home the point that this simple notion invalidated policy advice based on conclusions drawn from estimated system of equation models. Because the parameters of those models were not structural – that is, not policy-invariant – they would necessarily change whenever policy – the rules of the game – was changed. Policy conclusions based on those models would therefore potentially be misleading. This argument called into question the prevailing large-scale econometric models that lacked foundations in dynamic economic theory.

The Lucas Critique suggests that if we want to predict the effect of a policy experiment, we should model the "deep parameters" (relating to preferences, technology and resource constraints) that govern "individual" behavior. We can then predict what individuals will do "taking into account" the change in policy, and then aggregate the individual decisions to calculate the macroeconomic effects of the policy change.

The Lucas Critique was influential not only because it cast doubt on many existing models, but also because it encouraged macroeconomists to build microfoundations for their models. Microfoundations had always been thought to be desirable; Lucas convinced many economists they were essential. Later Finn Kydland and Edward Prescott pioneered the use of microfoundations to formulate macroeconomic models. Contemporary macroeconomic models microfounded on the interaction of rational agents are often called dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) models.

Examples

One important application of the critique is its implication that the historical negative correlation between inflation and unemployment, known as the Phillips Curve, could break down if the monetary authorities attempted to exploit it. Permanently raising inflation in hopes that this would permanently lower unemployment would eventually cause firms' inflation forecasts to rise, altering their employment decisions.

For an especially simple example, note that Fort Knox has never been robbed. However, this does not mean the guards can safely be eliminated, since the incentive not to rob Fort Knox depends on the presence of the guards.

In other words, with the heavy security that exists at the fort today, criminals are unlikely to attempt a robbery because they know they are unlikely to succeed. But a change in security policy, like eliminating the guards for example, would lead criminals to reappraise the costs and benefits of robbing the fort. So just because there are no robberies under the current policy does not mean this should be expected to continue under all possible policies. Likewise, just because high inflation was associated with low unemployment under early-twentieth-century monetary policy does not mean we should expect high inflation to lead to low unemployment under all alternative monetary policy regimes.

Further reading

*Lucas, Robert (1976). "Econometric Policy Evaluation: A Critique." "Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy" 1: 19–46.

ee also

*Dynamic inconsistency
*Real business cycles
*Policy Ineffectiveness Proposition
*Goodhart's Law
*Rational Expectations
*Model (macroeconomics)
*Methodological individualism


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Lucas (surname) — Lucas is a surname. It is probably a contraction of Latin Lucanus , lit. of Lucania . Lucania itself took its name from the Lucani who came to dominate the area for a time.People with the surname Lucas*Andrea Lucas, blonde *Albert Lucas, American …   Wikipedia

  • Critique De Lucas — La critique de Lucas, formulée par Robert Lucas Jr en 1976[1] a apporté un changement important dans la façon dont les modèles économétriques sont construits. Lucas a étudié la façon dont les agents forment leurs anticipations de l avenir, qui… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Critique de lucas — La critique de Lucas, formulée par Robert Lucas Jr en 1976[1] a apporté un changement important dans la façon dont les modèles économétriques sont construits. Lucas a étudié la façon dont les agents forment leurs anticipations de l avenir, qui… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Lucas D'Heere — Deux Pairs anglais, l’un vêtu des robes parlementaires et l’autre de celles de l’Ordre de la Ja …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Lucas Moreno — le 4 juin 2011 (photo: Alexander E. Harbaugh) Activités …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Lucas Mebrouk Dolega — (* 19. August 1978[1] in Paris; † 17. Januar 2011[2] in Tunis) war ein deutsch französischer Fotojournalist. Dolega starb am 17. Januar 2011, nachdem er wenige Tage zuvor im Zuge der Berichterstattung von den Ausschreitungen in Tunis von einer… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Critique Du Mormonisme — La critique du mormonisme porte sur les doctrines, les pratiques et l’histoire de l’Église de Jésus Christ des saints des derniers jours. L Église a en effet été l’objet de critiques dès sa création par Joseph Smith en raison de ses croyances en… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Lucas Belvaux — (* 14. November 1961 in Namur) ist ein belgischer Schauspieler, Drehbuchautor und Filmregisseur. Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Biografie 2 Filmografie (Auswahl) 2.1 Darsteller …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Critique de Lucas — La critique de Lucas, formulée par Robert Lucas Jr en 1976[1] a apporté un changement important dans la façon dont les modèles économétriques sont construits. Lucas a étudié la façon dont les agents forment leurs anticipations de l avenir, qui… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Lucas-Kritik — Die Lucas Kritik ist ein in den 1970er Jahren entstandenes wirtschaftstheoretisches Konzept der modernen Makroökonomik, mit dem wirtschaftspolitische Verhaltensweisen und deren Auswirkungen erklärt werden können. Vater des Konzepts ist der… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”