Beswick v. Beswick

Beswick v. Beswick

"Beswick v. Beswick" (1966) Ch. 538, [1968] AC 58 is a landmark English contract case on privity of contract.

Background

Lord Denning described the facts of the case::"Old Peter Beswick was a coal merchant in Eccles, Lancashire. He had no business premises. All he had was a lorry, scales, and weights. He used to take the lorry to the yard of the National Coal Board, where he bagged coal and took it round to his customers in the neighbourhood. His nephew, John Joseph Beswick, helped him in his business. In March 1962, old Peter Beswick and his wife were both over 70. He had had his leg amputated and was not in good health. The nephew was anxious to get hold of the business before the old man died. So they went to a solicitor, Mr. Ashcroft, who drew up an agreement for them".

The agreement was that Peter assign his business to his nephew in consideration of the nephew employing him for the rest of his life and then paying a weekly annuity to Mrs. Beswick. Since the latter term was for the benefit of someone not party to the contract, the nephew did not believe it was enforceable and so did not perform it, making only one payment of the agreed weekly amount of 5 pounds.

Opinion of the Court

The nephew argued that as Mrs Beswick was not a party to the contract, she was not able to enforce it due to the doctrine of Privity.

The Court held that this was true, and that she could not enforce the contract as herself. However they allowed her to recover as she had been appointed as the Administratrix of her husband's estate (he had not left a will), and as such was able to enforce the contract. She was, in her capacity as administratrix, entitled to an order for specific performance. In a separate opinion, Lord Denning held that the widow could not only sue as administratrix of the estate, but as third party beneficiary. In his view, the third-party beneficiary rule was not founded on earlier authority and would have led to an inequitable result.

The case was appealed to the House of Lords where the Lordships sided with the majority, while rejecting Lord Denning's contention that the widow could sue as beneficiary.

ee also

* [http://www.personalweb.unito.it/ugo.mattei/Beswick%20v%20Beswick.htm full text of House of Lords decision]
* [http://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKHL/1967/2.html Full text of decision from bailii.org]
* "Coulls v Bagot’s Executor and Trustee Co Ltd" (1967) 119 CLR 460. In this Australian case, the contract was between the husband and the company, not the wife, so she wasn’t a party to it. Even if she was, she wouldn’t be able to enforce it, as she gave no consideration. She did get it though, as executor of her husband’s estate. This is more of a consideration case but also touches on Privity.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать реферат

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Beswick — may refer to:*Beswick, East Riding of Yorkshire *Beswick, Greater Manchester …   Wikipedia

  • Beswick — est un quartier de Manchester, au nord ouest de l Angleterre. Il est traversé par la rivière Medlock et le canal Ashton. Il avoisine le district de plus grande taille de Bradford et on se réfère parfois à ces deux zones comme Bradford with… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Beswick, East Riding of Yorkshire — infobox UK place country = England latitude = 53.919520 longitude = 0.460195 official name = Beswick population = 372 (2001 census) civil parish = Beswick unitary england = East Riding of Yorkshire region = Yorkshire and the Humber lieutenancy… …   Wikipedia

  • Beswick — Martine Beswick (* 26. September 1941 in Port Antonio, Jamaika; auch Martine Beswicke) ist eine jamaikanische Schauspielerin. Sie ist ein Modell und Gewinnerin von Schönheitswettbewerben, die ins Filmgeschäft wechselte. Im Jahr 1958 gewann sie im …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Beswick, Greater Manchester — Infobox UK place country = England official name= Beswick latitude= 53.474256 longitude= 2.202663 population= metropolitan borough= City of Manchester metropolitan county= Greater Manchester region = North West England constituency westminster=… …   Wikipedia

  • Beswick — This is an interesting medieval locational name from one of two places called Beswick, one in Lancashire and the other in Yorkshire. The latter is first recorded as Baswic in the 1086 Domesday Book, although the Lancashire village as Beswiche is… …   Surnames reference

  • Martine Beswick — Born September 26, 1941 (1941 09 26) (age 70) Port Antonio, Jamaica Occupation Actress, model Years active 1962 1995 Martine Beswick (born 26 September 1941) is an Englis …   Wikipedia

  • Bob Beswick — Infobox rugby league biography playername = Bob Beswick fullname = Robert Beswick caption = country = position = Loose Forward currentclub = Halifax RLFC dateofbirth = birth date and age|1984|12|8 placeofbirth = countryofbirth = England height =… …   Wikipedia

  • Allan Beswick — is a radio broadcaster who presents the lunchtime show on BBC Radio Manchester in Manchester. [cite web last = first = authorlink = coauthors = title = Allan Beswick work = BBC Radio Manchester publisher = BBC date = 2006 03 31 url =… …   Wikipedia

  • Frank Beswick, Baron Beswick — (1911, Nottingham Strong Co op voices , The Co operative News , p.18, 13 May 2008.] 17 August 1987) was a British Labour Co operative politician.Beswick s father was a coal miner. Beswick was educated in Nottingham then at the Working Men s… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”