Kansas v. Colorado

Kansas v. Colorado

Kansas v. Colorado is a longstanding litigation before the Supreme Court of the United States between two states of the United States, Kansas and Colorado. The Court has rendered numerous opinions in this case:

  • Kansas v. Colorado, 185 U.S. 125 (1902)
  • Kansas v. Colorado, 206 U.S. 46 (1907)
  • Colorado v. Kansas, 320 U.S. 383 (1943)
  • Kansas v. Colorado, 514 U.S. 673 (1995)
  • Kansas v. Colorado, 533 U.S. 1 (2001)

When two states have a controversy between each other, the case is filed for original jurisdiction with the United States Supreme Court. This is one of the very limited circumstances where the court acts with original jurisdiction, i.e., as a trial court. In all other cases the court acts as the highest level appellate court in the United States.

Contents

1902

The issue in the case in 1902 (185 U.S. 125) was whether Colorado, as is claimed by Kansas, is taking too much of the water of the Arkansas River, making the land along the river in Kansas much less valuable due to reduced water flow. The court chose to delay making a decision until all of the facts were in evidence.

1907

In the 1907 case (206 U.S. 46), the Supreme Court affirmed its authority to settle the dispute between the states, but at the same time dismissed Kansas's petition on other grounds. After examining over 8,000 pages of transcripts that had been produced as a result of the litigation, it found that the "perceptible injury to portions of the Arkansas valley in Kansas" was justified by "the reclamation of large areas in Colorado, transforming thousands of acres into fertile fields." The court explicitly invited Kansas to institute new proceedings if the situation worsened significantly.

1943

In the 1943 decision (320 U.S. 383), the court found:

  1. Colorado is entitled to an injunction against further prosecution of suits by Kansas against Colorado users [of the Arkansas River].
  2. Kansas v. Colorado, 206 U. S. 46, made no allocation between the States of the waters of the river.
  3. Kansas is not entitled on the record to an apportionment in second feet or acre feet.
  4. In controversies involving the relative rights of States, the burden on the complaining State is much heavier than that generally required to be borne by private parties, and this Court will intervene only where a case is fully and clearly proved.
  5. Kansas' allegations that Colorado's use has materially increased since the [1907] decision in Kansas v. Colorado, and that the increase has worked a serious detriment to the substantial interests of Kansas, are not sustained by the evidence.
  6. Relief other than the restraint of further prosecution of suits by Kansas against Colorado users [of Arkansas River water] is denied to both States.

1995

In the 1995 case (514 U.S. 673), the court stated

Kansas and Colorado negotiated [and Congress approved in 1949] the Arkansas River Compact to settle disputes and remove causes of future controversies over the river’s waters and to equitably divide and apportion those waters and the benefits arising from the United States’ construction, operation, and maintenance of John Martin Reservoir.

A special master decided that

  • certain extra pumping of water in Colorado violates Article IV-D of the compact
  • Kansas has failed to prove that the operation of Colorado’s Winter Water Storage Program violates the Compact; and
  • dismiss Kansas’ claim that Colorado’s failure to abide by the Trinidad Reservoir Operating Principles violates the Compact.

Kansas and Colorado both filed exceptions to the Special Master's report. The court overruled the objections and found the special master's rulings correct on these points.

2001

In the 2001 decision (533 U.S. 1), a special master ordered Colorado to pay damages for its use of water in excess of what it was entitled to have from 1969 on. Colorado objected to the decision because in addition to monetary damages, it had to pay prejudgment interest from 1969, and Kansas objected to the settlement because it was granted an award in money rather than in water. The court sided with the special master on both points: Colorado has to pay interest on the judgment, and all Kansas gets is cash.

See also

External links


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем решить контрольную работу

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Kansas City metropolitan area — Kansas City, MO KS Common name: Kansas City Metropolitan Area Largest city Kansas City, Missouri Other cities …   Wikipedia

  • Colorado MahlerFest — is an annual event held in Boulder, Colorado, which each year celebrates one major symphonic work by Austrian composer Gustav Mahler. While Colorado MahlerFest is the official name of the event and the organization, the individual annual events… …   Wikipedia

  • Kansas and Oklahoma Railroad — Infobox SG rail railroad name=Kansas Oklahoma Railroad marks=KO system map size = 300 locale=Kansas, Oklahoma, Colorado start year=2001| end year=present hq city=Wichita, Kansas The Kansas and Oklahoma Railroad reporting mark|KO is a class III… …   Wikipedia

  • Colorado Territory — Colorado (Details) (Details) …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Colorado-Territorium — Kansas , Nebraska , Utah und New Mexico Territorien (1860) Das Colorado Territorium war ein historisches Hoheitsgebiet der Vereinigten Staaten, das vom 28. Februar 1861 bis zum 1. August 1876 bestand. Dann wurde das Territorium als 38.… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Colorado Rockies (NHL) — Colorado Rockies Gründung 8. Juni 1972 Geschichte Kansas City Scouts 1974 – 1976 Colorado Rockies …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Colorado Rapids U23's — Full name Colorado Rapids U23 s Nickname(s) Rapids Founded 2000 …   Wikipedia

  • Colorado gubernatorial election, 2010 — 2006 ← November 2, 2010 → 2014 …   Wikipedia

  • Colorado Storm — Founded 2004 League ABA Team history Colorado Storm 2004 2005 Arena Cougar Field House (2004) Wildcat Center (2004) …   Wikipedia

  • Kansas City Scouts — Gründung 8. Juni 1972 Geschichte Kansas City Scouts 1974 – 1976 Colorado Rockies …   Deutsch Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”