Warnock's Dilemma

Warnock's Dilemma

Warnock's Dilemma, named for its originator Bryan Warnock, is the problem of interpreting a lack of response to a posting on a mailing list, Usenet newsgroup, or Web forum. It occurs because a lack of response does not necessarily imply that no one is interested in the topic, and could have any one of several different implications, some of which are contradictory. Commonly used in the context of trying to determine why a post has not been replied to, or to refer to a post that has not been replied to.

Original description

There are other reasons one might not comment besides the ones Warnock enumerated. For example, perhaps writing a good reply would require doing research that the reader lacks the time to undertake. Perhaps one has a mild interest in the topic raised but doesn't feel qualified to comment. Or perhaps an overly insightful reply would commit one to additional work (common on software development lists, where the people who display the most knowledge about a feature often find themselves volunteered to implement it) but the reader doesn't want to get involved.

It can probably be safely assumed in most situations that not everyone who does not reply to a posting refrains for the same reason, as a literal reading of Warnock's original list might imply. Indeed, Warnock's original description goes on to explain, "Most of the time, there's not even a group consensus on the reason."

Common usage

Since Warnock's original description of the dilemma in August 2000, the expression has become widely used in the Perl world [ [http://www.nntp.perl.org/group/perl.perl6.language/15407 Re: Warnocked?] -- Post to the Perl 6 language list explaining history and uptake of term] and has seen some adoption by webloggers. [ [http://www.google.com/search?q=warnock%27s+dilemma+blog Google search of use of term on blogs] ] It is commonly used to refer to the uncertainty of deciding which of any number of reasons caused an absence of responses. Oft-seen phrases include:

; "He was Warnocked." [ [http://www.landgren.net/perl/p5psumm/20050919.xrl.html#in_brief This Week on perl5-porters - 19-25 September 2005] ] :

Someone posted a question, but nobody replied.

; "Warnock applies." [ [http://dev.perl.org/perl6/list-summaries/2006/p6summary.2006-01-11.html Perl 6 Summary for 2006-01-02 though 2006-01-09] ] :

Warns readers not to draw conclusions based on the lack of response.

Linguistic aspects

Traditionally, a dilemma has exactly two choices, both unfavorable, which would mean that Warnock's Dilemma as originally phrased is not a true dilemma. Properly speaking it is a logical disjunction. However, many modern dictionaries consider this restriction needless and allow "dilemma" to be used colloquially to refer to a difficult situation with any number of choices [ [http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=dilemma&x=0&y=0 "Dilemma"] , Dictionary.com] , since the term Polylemma, which is the appropriate description, has not come to widespread use. Alternatively, the literal-minded can consider the Dilemma to be about whether people aren't replying to messages because 1) they aren't interested, or 2) for some other reason.

Notes and references

External links

* [http://www.nntp.perl.org/group/perl.perl6.language/15407 Warnock's later explanations]
* [http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/9.10/mustread.html?pg=7 Mention in Wired Jargon Watch]
* [http://metatalk.metafilter.com/mefi/9429 MetaTalk discussion about the dilemma]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Warnock — is a surname, and may refer to:* Billy Warnock (f.l 1930s), Belfast boxer, brother of Jimmy Warnock * Bob Warnock, a sailor on the deck of the submarine, USS Cachalot , when the attack on Pearl Harbor began * Bryan Warnock, originator of Warnock… …   Wikipedia

  • Dilemma — For other uses, see Dilemma (disambiguation). Between a rock and a hard place redirects here. For other uses, see Between a Rock and a Hard Place (disambiguation). A dilemma (Greek: δί λημμα double proposition ) is a problem offering at least two …   Wikipedia

  • Internet forum — The phpBB Internet Forum software package, one of the most popular forum packages …   Wikipedia

  • Дилемма Уорнока — Дилемма Уорнока, названная в честь ее автора Брайана Уорнока (англ. Bryan Warnock), заключается в том, что отсутствие реакции на сообщение в списке рассылки, Usenet новостях или Интернет форуме можно понимать по разному. Отсутствие реакции… …   Википедия

  • Berkeley, George — George Berkeley David Berman BACKGROUND AND EARLY WORK George Berkeley was born on 12 March 1685 in Co. Kilkenny, where he spent his early years. His father was from England, his mother (very probably) was born in Ireland.1 After attending… …   History of philosophy

  • Mary Whitehouse — For the British comedy show, see The Mary Whitehouse Experience. Mary Whitehouse, CBE (born Constance Mary Hutcheson, 13 June 1910 – 23 November 2001) was a British campaigner against the permissive society particularly as the media portrayed and …   Wikipedia

  • Steve McManaman — Personal information Full name Steven …   Wikipedia

  • language, philosophy of — Philosophical study of the nature and use of natural languages and the relations between language, language users, and the world. It encompasses the philosophical study of linguistic meaning (see semantics), the philosophical study of language… …   Universalium

  • Islāmic world — Introduction  prehistory and history of the Islamic community.       Adherence to Islām is a global phenomenon: Muslims predominate in some 30 to 40 countries, from the Atlantic to the Pacific and along a belt that stretches across northern… …   Universalium

  • Estrogen — Estriol. Note two hydroxyl ( OH) groups attached to the D ring (rightmost ring) …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”